The Prophets – Robert Jones, Jr.

Expectation: A remarkable debut novel giving a queer perspective to the experiences of those held in slavery in pre-Civil War America.

Reality: Gorgeous writing, memorable characters and a tense last third help overcome a somewhat confusing structure. This is a book people will talk about all year.

A Monster Calls – Patrick Ness

Expectation: A mushy, hopeful tale of a teen manifesting a monster to help him grapple with the death of a parent and the ways it will change his life.

Reality: A simply told, yet incredibly impactful exploration of the ways in which we lie to ourselves.

Betty – Tiffany McDaniel

Expectation: The female “A Little Life.”

Reality: The most depressing book I’ve ever read, yet there was something still beautiful about its pain and misery.

Recommended For: People that like character driven stories, especially those about Americana.